Buddhism in Times of Radical Changes edited by Humanity
Host: Ven. Chang Hwa(Director of Dharma Drum Mountain Chan Meditation Center, New York)
Speaker:
1.Jakusho Kwong Roshi (Founder of Sonoma Mountain Zen Center)
2.Rev. Meian Elbert (Abbess of Shasta Abbey)
3.Ven. Phap Kham (Executive Director of the Plum Village Foundation Hong Kong & Dharma Teacher)
4.Ven. Guo Huei (Abbot President of Dharma Drum Mountain)
Ven. Chang Hwa: All the Ven.s and all the guest speakers, and the participants, it's a pleasure today to have all the masters here. Today we are going to invite them to share their great insight and their practice to help us to go through all the chaotic changes that we are facing today. As religious Buddhist practice organizations, all of them have the same goal: to be awakened and to get enlightened. However, the process is very challenging.
So first, we are honored to have our Ven. Phap Kham, who is the Executive Director of the Plum Village Foundation Hong Kong, and also the Dharma Teacher. And next is Ven. Guo Huei, Vice Abbot President of Dharma Drum Mountain, and Dean of Dharma Drum Institute of Liberal Arts. And next is Rev. Meian Elbert, Abbess of Shasta Abbey. And the last is Jakusho Kwong Roshi, Founder of Sonoma Mountain Zen Center.
First I would like to invite all of you to briefly introduce your tradition, your practice, and what is the core value that cannot be changed, and what can be changed?
Rev. Meian Elbert: I am from Shasta Abbey, which is a monastery in Northern California, in America. We have male and female monastics training together. We have about twenty-three of us at the moment. We are celibate, we don't eat meat or drink alcohol, and we keep to the Soto Zen tradition. We are part of a larger order called the Order of Buddhist Contemplatives, which has- as well as our monastery- another monastery in Northern England, and a number of smaller temples in Europe, North America, and Britain. So we are a part of a larger group, and our basic principle is the practice of traditional Dharma. We also practice the upholding of the fourfold Sangha, monastics and lay people, male and female, because we feel, I feel particularly, that you need both lay trainees, male and female, and monastics, male and female, for the benefit of Buddhism.
So a large part of what we do is training monastics, because if we don't train the monks, who's going to do it? We are also teaching lay trainees. We do Dharma Talks. We put some of our talks online for people to hear who want to. We publish books. Some of them are available for free-download on our website. But a large part of it is simply teaching the Buddhadharma, traditional Buddhist teaching, such as the Four Noble Truths, the Eightfold Path, the Three Characteristics: dukkha, anicca, anatt?.
Basic Buddhist teaching is, I feel, still applicable in our modern day. Even though things are different, they are not that different. The human heart is still the same. There is still the same problem, really, in a different dress. It just seems more intense now. But I think that it's really still the same old greed, hatred and delusion that we've always had. We just need to learn how to train with it, convert it, to learn to live together in this world. It seems harder now, because of the internet. Everybody is connected. Everybody is seeing what everybody else is doing, for better or worse. There are wonderful things about the internet: it means that we can spread the Dharma. And yet it also means people take a little bit of this, now a little bit of that. And this can be diluted by our own views, as Kwong Roshi was saying. It's easy to pick and choose and to take what you want and miss the root. But the root, the fundamental teachings of the Buddha, are nevertheless still completely applicable in our day and age, and this is what we teach. That's what I teach. And also the practice of kindness, because meditation, scripture, scholarship can intimidate people, but anyone can practice kindness- and Buddhism is kindness.
And I think of all the things that we need in this world today, kindness is foremost. So that is what I try to teach: meditation, keeping to the precepts, kindness, compassion, and patience with others who don't think the way we do. Generosity of thought, deed and word, and trying to live the Buddha's path by example as well as by teaching: teaching ourselves, teaching our young monks, teaching the lay people who want to come. We don't charge fees so that people who don't have much money can come to train at our temple, and in our other temples too.
Jakusho Kwong Roshi:Yes, calmness, kindness, generosity- Dana is very important. Jetsunma Tenzin Palmo, who is the first woman practitioner to be recognized as an official teacher in the Tibetan tradition, visited us just a few months ago. Jetsunma is known as the only westerner to sit in a cave for a long time. If you ask her what her experience was, she may not say, as she prefers to speak about the present not the past. She said when visiting China, the Communist government, as well as the people, are realizing that Buddhism is good for their society. This means the Communist Party and the people are familiar with Dharma's simplicity, goodness, integrity and nobility. They recognize the basic goodness and character of the Buddhadharma, I feel this is a very good sign because this allows the Dharma to still flourish in China. In turn, these benefits bring out the basic goodness and character for their people and country.
Like I mentioned earlier, the word "practice" is overused. We really should investigate it. Practice is what? There was an auspicious awakening event in China hundreds of years ago that twenty monks who took a bath all together. As recorded in the Buddhist history, the whole gathering of monks was enlightened simultaneously. Because they practiced and what was the "practice"? Touching the water. That's practice, not using the water, but touching it. And by touching water our bodies and minds become clean and pure. I like this story very much. We should remember that when we are practicing, we are not doing something for a purpose. Keeping in mind the Dharma, along with your action, is one single moment. It's the moment of the instant, before the present.
Ven. Chang Hwa: And what is the method that you teach people how to touch the water?
Jakusho Kwong Roshi: I can only demonstrate it. Ultimately, each and every one must do it for themselves to discover this truth. I am not even sure that "method" or "teaching" is the right word, either. We demonstrate it. That's what happens. We demonstrate it.
(Roshi remains in silence, transmitting the calmness of what touching is- water is wet......)
Ven. Chang Hwa: So your organization is Soto?
Jakusho Kwong Roshi: Yes, Soto Zen.
Ven. Chang Hwa: So the method of no method?
Jakusho Kwong Roshi: The method of no method. It is the strict. Method without method means that this includes all methods. It is just like when you sit. What do you call Zazen?
Ven. Chang Hwa: Zazen, we call Chan.
Jakusho Kwong Roshi: Chan, yes! Just like when you sit, there is a severe limitation. For instance, a round zafu/cushion placed on a three by three-foot zabuton/mat. Through this limitation, you find the freedom. And it's within years of sitting- it is said that possibly twenty or thirty years- it is of essence of your way-seeking mind which holds the courage, doubt and aspiration for the ultimate Truth must be present. Our ancestors throughout space and time have all demonstrated the Dharma and instructed in this way.
Ven. Chang Hwa: Ven. Phap Kham, please introduce your tradition, practice and core values that cannot be changed.
Ven. Phap Kham: Dear Ven. monks, nuns and sangha, I am from Plum Village Hong Kong, a meditation practice center in the tradition of Thich Nhat Hanh and Plum Village. And you see, I am wearing a sunflower with the word "SMILE."